Contesting / challenge an executor of a will
Find out how we can support you in challenging an executor and resolving disputes over the administration of an estate.
Contact our teamContest / challenge an executor or administrator of a will
Find out how we can support you in challenging an executor and resolving disputes over the administration of an estate. Our expert legal team provides guidance on protecting your rights and ensuring the executor fulfils their duties fairly and lawfully. Contact us on 023 8071 8000 to learn more or fill in our enquiry form.
Should you suspect that the executor or administrator of a loved one’s will is failing to fulfil their responsibilities, you have the option to take action against them. Their obligations involve gathering the assets of the deceased and allocating them as outlined in the will.
What is challenging an executor of will?
Challenging an executor of a will involves contesting the actions or decisions made by the person responsible for administering a deceased person’s estate. This can be done if there are concerns about their competence, misconduct, or failure to fulfil terms of a Will
Can a beneficiary challenge an executor?
Yes, a beneficiary can challenge an executor if they believe the executor is mismanaging the estate, acting dishonestly, or failing to fulfil their legal duties.
What are the responsibilities of an executor of a will?
The responsibilities of an executor of a Will are mainly administrative and can include:
- Gathering and managing assets: You are responsible for identifying and collecting all the assets of the deceased person, such as bank accounts, investments, real estate, and personal belongings. You must also ensure that these assets are properly managed and protected during the probate process. You may need an official Grant of Probate to do this.
- Paying debts and taxes: You are responsible for identifying and paying off any outstanding debts or taxes owed by the deceased person, from the estate. This may involve working with creditors, filing tax returns, and settling any outstanding financial obligations.
- Distributing assets to beneficiaries: Once all debts and taxes have been paid, you are responsible for distributing the remaining assets to the beneficiaries named in the will. This may involve selling assets, transferring ownership, or distributing funds according to the instructions outlined in the will.
- Managing legal proceedings: As an executor, you may need to initiate or respond to legal proceedings related to the estate, such as filing the will with the probate registry, defending the will against challenges, or resolving any disputes among beneficiaries.
- Keeping accurate records: Throughout the entire process, it is crucial to maintain detailed and accurate records of all financial transactions, communications, and decisions made on behalf of the estate. This includes keeping track of expenses, receipts, and any correspondence related to the estate administration.
What are the grounds for making a claim against an executor of a will?
An executor is appointed to administer the estate of a deceased person according to the terms set out in their will and in accordance with the law. However, there may be circumstances where an executor’s conduct or decisions come into question. The grounds for making a claim against an executor of a will include:
Breach of fiduciary duty
Executors owe a duty of loyalty, honesty, and good faith to the beneficiaries of the will. They must act in the best interests of the estate. If they misuse or misappropriate estate assets or prioritise their interests above the beneficiaries’, they can be held liable for breach of fiduciary duty.
Mismanagement of estate assets
If an executor negligently manages the assets of the estate, resulting in financial loss, they can be held accountable. Examples include failing to insure valuable assets, neglecting to collect debts owed to the estate, or selling assets for less than their true value.
Failure to distribute assets
Beneficiaries can bring a claim if the executor unduly delays the distribution of estate assets or fails to distribute them in accordance with the will.
Failure to provide an account
Executors are required to maintain accurate records of their dealings and provide a detailed account of the administration of the estate. If they fail to provide this when requested, it can form the basis of a claim.
Conflict of interest
An executor should not have any personal interest that conflicts with their duty. If they make decisions which benefit them personally at the expense of the beneficiaries, it may give rise to a claim.
Overcharging
If an executor is taking fees or expenses from the estate that are excessive or not justifiable, beneficiaries can challenge the amounts being claimed.
Failure to pay taxes and debts
Executors have the responsibility to pay any taxes or outstanding debts of the deceased from the estate’s assets. If they fail to do this promptly, they can be held personally liable.
Improper investments
While managing the assets, if the executor makes investments that are not considered prudent and result in a loss to the estate, they may be held responsible.
Ignoring or misinterpreting the will
If the executor fails to follow the instructions outlined in the will or misinterprets them, it could provide grounds for a claim.
If beneficiaries believe that an executor has failed in their duties, it’s essential to seek legal advice. It may be possible to resolve concerns amicably without resorting to litigation. However, if concerns are not addressed, it might be necessary to apply to the court to remove and replace the executor or seek redress for any loss caused.
Our team of private wealth disputes solicitors
Why choose our private wealth dispute solicitors?
Here at Moore Barlow LLP, our Private Wealth Dispute solicitors have extensive experience in handling complex and sensitive disputes, providing tailored advice and practical solutions to protect and preserve your interests. With a deep understanding of the intricacies of challenging an executor of a will, we offer a collaborative and strategic approach to achieve the best possible outcome for you. Trust us to navigate the legal complexities and safeguard your interests.
How can our private wealth dispute solicitors help?
Our Private Wealth Dispute solicitors are experts in resolving disputes related to challenging an executor of a will. We provide tailored advice and representation to individuals and families in complex and high-stakes cases. Our team adopts a strategic and proactive approach to achieve the best possible outcome for our clients, whether through negotiation, mediation, or litigation. We understand the sensitivity and emotional impact of these disputes and strive to provide a supportive and empathetic service throughout the process.
We have offices in London, Richmond, Southampton, Guildford, Lymington and Woking and offer specialist legal services to clients nationwide.
Contact our private wealth disputes team
Contentious probate – FAQs
What to do if you are unhappy with an executor?
If a beneficiary has concerns about an executor’s actions, they can first request a formal account of the estate administration. If the response is unsatisfactory or raises further issues, the beneficiary may apply to the court to have the executor removed and replaced.
Who can challenge an executor / administrator of a will?
Interested parties, such as beneficiaries named in the will or those who have inherited if there was no Will can potentially challenge an executor. They may do so if they believe the executor is not fulfilling their duties properly or if they suspect fraud or misconduct.
Can you remove an executor / administrator of a will?
Yes, it is possible to remove an executor or administrator. This can be done through a court process by filing an application for removal and providing evidence of misconduct, incompetence, or failure to fulfil their duties. It is recommended to consult with a lawyer experienced in probate and estate law for assistance with this matter.
What action can be taken against an executor of a will?
The executor is responsible for managing the estate, but if you believe they are failing in their duties—such as mismanaging assets or distributing them incorrectly—you may have grounds to take legal action. In some cases, you can apply to the court to have the executor removed and replaced.
Can you overrule an executor of a will?
An executor has a legal duty to administer the estate according to the terms of the will and relevant laws. While beneficiaries cannot directly overrule an executor, they can challenge their decisions if the executor is acting improperly. If an executor mismanages the estate, breaches their duties, or fails to act impartially, beneficiaries may take legal action to remove or replace them through the court.
Can you object to an executor of a will?
Yes, you can object to an executor if you believe they are unfit or unsuitable for the role. If probate has not yet been granted, you can raise concerns with the Probate Registry, outlining why the executor should not be appointed. If probate has already been issued, you may need to apply to the court to challenge their actions or seek their removal. Grounds for objection include conflicts of interest, dishonesty, incapacity, or failure to administer the estate properly.
How to contest an executor of a will
If you believe an executor is mismanaging an estate, acting dishonestly, or failing to fulfil their legal duties, you may have grounds to contest their role. Here are the key steps to take:
- Raise Concerns Directly – Start by writing to the executor, requesting a formal account of the estate administration. Executors must act transparently and provide updates to beneficiaries.
- Seek Mediation – If concerns remain, mediation can help resolve disputes without the need for court proceedings. This can be a quicker and more cost-effective solution.
- Apply to the Court – If the executor refuses to cooperate or continues to mismanage the estate, you can apply to the court to remove or replace them. You will need to provide evidence that the executor is failing in their duties, such as delays, improper asset distribution, or financial misconduct.
- Request an Inventory and Account – The court may order the executor to provide a full account of the estate’s assets and administration. If wrongdoing is found, further legal action can be taken.
- Legal Proceedings – In serious cases, such as fraud or gross negligence, court intervention may be necessary to prevent further harm to the estate.
Challenging an executor can be a complex process, so seeking specialist legal advice early is essential to protect your interests and ensure the estate is handled correctly.
Explore our latest private wealth dispute insights
Our team accreditations
